$12,250 per Household Tax Increase For Gov. Newsom’s Single-Payer Healthcare System Proposal

Tax Foundation says California will be doubling the state’s taxes

By Katy Grimes, California Globe

Higher Taxes proposed for single-payer healthcare system

Assembly Constitutional Amendment 11 was introduced last week in the California Legislature to enact significant tax increases to fund universal single-payer health care coverage in California, the Globe reported.

Single payer is a universal state-run healthcare system financed by taxpayers, that covers the costs of healthcare for all residents by a single public system.

Also last week, Assembly Bill 1400, the “Guaranteed Health Care for All” state-run healthcare bill, which has been kicking around the Assembly for several years now, was heard and passed in the Assembly Rules Committee, but not without some strong debate and some would say, rule breaking, or at least blurred lines enough to be a highly dubious passage.

The Tax Foundation reports “this will increase taxes by $12,250 per household, roughly doubling the state’s already high tax collections, to fund a first-in-the-nation single-payer health-care system.”

Previous statewide single payer healthcare proposals elicited estimates of more than $400 billion to implement. The entire 2022-23 state budget proposal is $286 billion.

“The top marginal rate on wage income would soar to 18.05 percent—nationally, the median top marginal rate is 5.3 percent—and the state would adopt a new 2.3 percent gross receipts tax (GRT), at a rate more than three times that of the country’s highest current pure GRT,” the Tax Foundation reported.

“All told, the new tax package is intended to raise an additional $163 billion per year, which is more than California raised in total tax revenue any year prior to the pandemic.”

They explain the new taxes would take three forms:

  1. Surtaxes atop the current individual income tax structure beginning at $149,509 in income;
  2. A graduated-rate payroll tax system with the top rate kicking in for employees with more than $49,990 in annual income; and
  3. A gross receipts tax of 2.3 percent, excluding the first $2 million of business income.

Gov. Newsom has been pushing for single-payer for several years

The Globe reported in July 2019:

California’s largest cities are reporting growing numbers of homeless, drug addicted and mentally-ill transients living on the streets, while Gov. Gavin Newsom is pushing his plan for single-payer “health care for all.” And, with approval from the governor, the California Legislature voted recently to tax California citizens who do not buy health insurance. This penalty revenue will be used to fund health insurance subsidies to encourage more people to purchase health insurance, and to provide health care to illegal immigrants.

Has anything really changed in two-and-a-half years other than more spending?

Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a bill in 2019 allowing illegal immigrants between the ages of 19 and 25 coverage under Medi-Cal, California’s health insurance program for the poor, disabled, and now for those living in the country and state illegally. State officials estimated about 90,000 additional people would quality at a cost of $98 million per year.

Also in late 2019, a three-judge panel with the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals struck down the federal Affordable Care Act (ACA)’s individual mandate. Immediately, Gov. Newsom issued a statement expressing his disagreement, and then drilled down announcing the launch of the Healthy California for All Commission to develop a plan for creating a Single Payer system in California.

Newsom mocked the reaction over the controversy the Medi-Cal expansion to illegal aliens generated: “To my friends at Fox News, I know we’re keeping you in business,” he said. He promised to continue expanding health coverage to more undocumented people in future years. “Universal health care is a right regardless of immigration status,” Newsom said. “I’m going to get the rest of that done, mark my words, and make progress next year and the year after that.”

As for the latest single payer healthcare system proposal creating the largest bureaucracy in state history, the Tax Foundation said, “And while 16 states either implemented or enacted individual or corporate income tax cuts in 2021, and more are looking to join them in 2022, California policymakers want voters to approve five new surtaxes, with a top rate of 2.5 percent atop the current 13.3 percent top marginal income tax rate and the proposed new 2.25 percent payroll tax, for a combined top marginal rate of 18.05 percent. This is more than 7 percentage points higher than the next-highest rates in Hawaii (11 percent), New York (10.9 percent), and New Jersey and the District of Columbia (both at 10.75 percent).”

The Globe spoke with Assemblyman Health Flora (R-Ripon) after passage of the “Guaranteed Health Care for All” state-run healthcare bill. “That means we are going to charge every taxpaying Californian making over $49,000,” he said. “ACA 11 is the funding source to AB 1400. When they realize they don’t have enough money to pay for this, they can raise taxes on everyone on a simple majority vote. They wrote that right into the bill. But anything fiscal has to be a 2/3 majority vote.”

Read the whole report from the Tax Foundation.

Source: http://www.capoliticalreview.com

Get Citizensjournal.us Headlines free  SUBSCRIPTION. Keep us publishing – DONATE

5 1 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

How do they figure only 12,250 more dollars per household when several studies of single payer healthcare nationally peg the number at 5.5 trillion dollars or 16,000 dollars PER PERSON?

Much like the high speed rail, which used lies to convince voters to fork over money now and worry about costs later when the truth came out, this amount is ludicrous.

Many workers have free health insurance from their employer or insurance that costs a few hundred a month, but remember, you will now be responsible for paying for you, your family and someone else’s family because they don’t make 16,000 per person.

It’s also often confused with national healthcare, like in the U.K. where the doctors and nurses are government employees and paid low wages. Nurses in the U.K. make less than a fast food worker in California and they will never stand for that here, it’s below our minimum wage.

What the plan is going to do is tax the heck out of those who actually work for a living without giving them any benefit. As I debated with Bernie Sanders supporters who would never tell me how much their plan would cost me, they would only say “you would get free healthcare with the tax increase”, to which I told them, “I have free healthcare now” (nothing is free, but my employer paid for it).

Michael A...

This fella we call “governor” is a tool of public employee unions. If this scheme of his ever becomes a reality it will become a huge bloated mess full of unionized over compensated employees adding to the misery we call California.

Last edited 1 day ago by Michael A...
Mike Smith

You’re absolutely right, All Unions should be found illegal. They take money away from the CEOs like Gates and Zuckerberg, and we all agree those guys need more, don’t we?

Michael A...

The fake Mike Smith speaks. No, unions should not be found illegal. The relationship between public employee unions and the Dem party is highly toxic and detrimental to citizens. The good old “one hand washes the other” has never had more meaning than in this example. Try thinking clearly for change fake Mike Smith, your schtick of jumping from one IP to the next has gotten stale.

Mike Smith

Hey fake Michael A, why don’t you stop with your fucked up allegations. My name is a Mike Smith so I fill in the form the way they ask. Fuck you if you think there’s another person posting under my name.

Grow up and smarten up you dildo.

William Hicks

More important, unions and politicians have an incestuous relationship. Politicians are always grateful to union funding for their elections/reelections and unions get laws in their favor from politicians.

Mike Smith

Anyone notice this guy won’t provide his last name? What a pussy.


This will impose a financial hardship on Californians. Californians who are covered by Medicare or Federal Health Insurance will end up paying taxes to support medical benefits not received. I would expect the exodus from California to increase, not only of citizens but more businesses that provide jobs to the community. This bill is bad news.

William Hicks

Illegal aliens are likely to get it free at a cost to tax paying Citizens. AND, as more Citizens leave the state, expect the cost to individual taxpayers to increase above the $12,250.00. Texas, Idaho, Montana and Florida are looking better every day.